First Team All Ohio
- Brian Hiscox
- Nick Burzanko
Regional Runner Up – 2006
District Champion – 2006, 2007, 2010, 2016
District Runner Up – 2005, 2009
Conference Champion – 1959, 1960, 1972, 1988, 2002, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, 2011, 2015
Team Records
- Wins in a Season – 26 (2006)
- Home Runs in a Season – 21 (2006)
- Triples in a Season – 6 (2007)
- Doubles in a Season – 56 (2007)
- Hits in a Season – 293 (2006)
- Batting Average in a Season – .348 (2005)
- Stolen Bases in a Season – 93 (2019)
- Runs Batted In in a Season – 259 (2006)
- Earned Run Average in a Season – 2.38 (2006)
- Strikeouts in a Season – 153 (2006)
Individual Pitching Records
- Wins (Season) – 8 (Jon Tiber, 2006)
- Strike Outs (Season) – 53 (David Keyes, 2001)
- Earned Run Average (Season, minimum 25 innings pitched) – 1.13 (Jon Tiber, 2006)
- Innings Pitched (Season) – 56.0 (Jon Tiber, 2006)
Individual Offensive Records
- Home Runs (Season) – 10 (Brian Hiscox, 2005)
- Triples (Season) – 2 (Brandon Heritage, 2001/David Keyes, 2001/Mike Smetana, 2006 & 2007/Aaron Pawlak, 2017/Sam Roach, 2018/Joe Barcikoski, 2019)
- Doubles (Season) – 12 (Zach Nichols, 2007)
- Hits (Season) – 43 (Brian Hiscox, 2005)
- Batting Average (Season, minimum 25 at bats) – .494 (Brian Hiscox, 2005)
- Runs Batted In (Season) – 52 (Brian Hiscox, 2005)
- Stolen Bases (Season) – 23 (Mike Smetana, 2006 & 2007)
- Runs Scored (Season) – 41 (Bryan Layne, 2007)